This or That Make-Along 2024: Both Crochet and Knit

Calling all crocheters and knitters, time to join the This or That Make-Along: Your Next Creative Adventure Awaits!

Are you ready to begin a creative journey with fellow crafters? The This or That Make-Along 2024 with Marly Bird is here, and it’s time to choose your path! Whether you’re a fan of crochet or knitting, this make-along has something special just for you —two sweaters, similar in shape but different in texture, cut, and fit, yet equal in popularity and style. So grab your yarn, and let’s dive into a month of creativity, community, and crafting fun!

Two images of Marly Bird, wearing similar glasses and hairstyles, each model a different red top. The left top is crocheted and the right top is knitted. The background text reads "This or That Make-Along." The words are in yellow and white with grey arrows pointing to each woman. -Marly Bird

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you.

What’s This or That Make-Along 2024 All About?

In this make-along, you have the exciting choice between two fabulous sweater patterns: the Bellini Crochet Sweater and the Sandra PDA Knit Sweater. These patterns are designed for advanced beginners to intermediate crafters, making them the perfect next step in your crafting journey.

  • The Bellini Crochet Sweater: A stunning piece crafted with fingering weight yarn, perfect for those who love the elegance and drape of finer yarns. Get the ad-free pdf here.
  • The Sandra PDA Knit Sweater: A cozy, versatile sweater made with worsted weight yarn, ideal for knitters who appreciate warmth and texture. Get the ad-free pdf here.

Learn About the Make-Along from Marly on Monday Aug. 19th 2024

Join Marly as she announces the make-along officially. ⏰ 10:15 am EST she will go live!

How Can You Participate in the Make-Along?

You can join us in one of two ways:

  1. Free Version on the Blog: Access the written instructions for free, right on the Marly Bird blog. Follow along at your own pace with ads supporting the content.
  2. Purchase Ad-Free PDF Version: For a streamlined, uninterrupted experience, purchase the ad-free PDF version of the pattern. This includes all the extras—video tutorials, stitch diagrams, and charts—all in one convenient download. 🌟 Plus, enjoy a special 25% off in the Marly Bird Etsy Store until August 31st at 11:59 PM—no coupon needed! ✅

Weekly Live Q&A Sessions

Throughout the make-along, Marly Bird will be hosting live Q&A sessions each week on the Marly Bird YouTube channel. These sessions are a great opportunity to ask questions, get tips, and connect with fellow crafters. Don’t forget to join the Marly Bird Facebook community for additional support and camaraderie!

script text that reads Marly's Minions

Video Support: Find Your Weekly Tutorials

Each week, new video tutorials will be released to guide you through the make-along. These videos will be available on the Marly Bird YouTube channel and will be linked directly from the blog post for easy access. Whether you’re working on the Bellini Crochet Sweater or the Sandra PDA Knit Sweater, you’ll find step-by-step instructions to help you every stitch of the way. Make sure to subscribe to the Marly Bird YouTube channel so you never miss an update!

image with text "learn on YouTube with Marly Bird", also includes the logo for YouTube and Marly Bird
A woman with curly blonde hair styled up is smiling and looking to the side. She is wearing red glasses and a cozy knit sweater over a black top. She has a ring on her right hand, which is touching her glasses. The neutral background features some decorative elements that add charm. -Marly Bird
A circular graphic with a gray background and the words "This or That" in bold, black and white text. The word "or" is highlighted with a yellow paint stroke behind it, reminiscent of a cozy crochet design. -Marly Bird
A person wearing glasses and a red crochet sweater over a black top stands indoors, smiling. They have blonde hair styled in curls. The background includes a gray wall with picture frames, a white sofa, and a decorative wall piece. -Marly Bird

Why You’ll Love the Ad-Free PDF

Choosing the ad-free PDF version isn’t just about convenience; it’s about elevating your crafting experience. Here’s why:

  • No Interruptions: Enjoy a seamless crafting journey without the distraction of ads.
  • Comprehensive Content: Get access to exclusive video tutorials, stitch diagrams, and charts that aren’t available in the free version.
  • All in One Place: Download and keep your pattern for easy access anytime, anywhere.

❣️Remember: the 25% off is only available in the Marly Bird Etsy Store until Aug. 31 @ 11:59pm EST.

Bellini- Get the Ad-Free PDF

A completely black image with no visible content or discernible patterns. -Marly Bird

Purchasing the ad-free PDF of the Bellini Crochet Cropped Sweater Pattern is a fantastic option for those who want a seamless, uninterrupted crafting experience. This convenient format allows you to easily follow along without distractions, and it’s perfect for printing out and taking on-the-go for your crochet projects.

The PDF includes fully formatted pattern with written instructions, schematic, crochet stitch diagrams, full pattern charts for each size, and video tutorial links.

A promotional image features a woman wearing a stunning red Bellini Crochet Sweater, smiling and posing next to a tablet and smartphone displaying the pattern. Several detailed crochet pattern sheets surround the devices, showcasing intricate instructions and diagrams. -Marly Bird
Bellini Crochet Sweater Ad-Free PDF

Sandra- Get the Ad-Free PDF

A completely black image with no visible content or discernible patterns. -Marly Bird

Ready to cast on? Your purchase includes an instant download of the Sandra PDA Cropped Knit Sweater pattern PDF, complete with ✨32 pages✨ of detailed instructions and high-quality images.

The PDF includes fully formatted pattern with written instructions, schematic, crochet stitch diagrams, full pattern charts for each size, and video tutorial links.

An image showcasing a digital pattern for the "Cropped Knit Sweater" by Sandra Payge. It features a tablet and smartphone displaying the pattern, along with printed instruction pages detailing the knitting process, charts, and images of this must-have sweater. -Marly Bird
Sandra PDA Knit SweaterAd-Free PDF

Ready to Start?

Mark your calendars, gather your supplies, and get ready to create something beautiful. Whether you’re making the Bellini Crochet Sweater or the Sandra PDA Knit Sweater, you’re in for a rewarding and fun experience.

To join the fun and get a full materials list, fill out the form below ⬇️

This or That Make-Along 2024

Join the fun with hundreds of other knitters and crocheters for this free Marly Bird Make-Along

    We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Join us for the “This or That Make-Along” and see which path you’ll choose!


    FAQ: This or That Make-Along

    Q: When does the make-along start and end?
    A: The make-along runs from August 30th to September 27th, 2024.

    • Make-Along Announcement – Aug. 19 – Watch Video Here
    • Get Ready: Gauge Swatch Information and Choosing Sizes – Aug. 23th – Watch Video Here
    • Week 1: Aug. 30th
    • Week 2: Sept. 6th
      • Knitting Video — click here
        • follow along with the Row by Row Worksheet from week 1
      • Crochet Instructions — No video for this week as you are supposed to work up the front of the Bellini sweater to the start of the neckline.
    • ⭐️ BONUS ⭐️ Join the LIVE Q & A on Monday Sept. 9th at 7:30 pm on the Marly Bird YouTube Channel.
    • Week 3: Sept. 13th
      • Knitting Video — click here
        • follow along with the Row by Row Worksheet from week 1
      • Crochet Video — Join the Live @ 5:30 ET Sept. 13, 2024 — click here
    • Week 4: Sept. 20th — Work Week — No Lessons.
    • Week 5: Sept. 27th
      • Knitting Video — click here
      • Crochet Video — click here
        • After reading some feedback I think you all need one more weekend to get to where you are ready to seam the sweater. So I will do the live on Monday Night 🙂

    Q: How do I join the make-along?
    A: You can participate by following the free version of the pattern on the blog or by purchasing the ad-free PDF version from the Marly Bird Etsy Store.

    ❣️Note: these patterns are not in the Marly Bird House, unless you purchased the BiCrafty Stitch-Nite Collection which does have the Sandra PDA included.

    A collage of various knitted items including socks, mittens, hats, a sweater, and cabled accessories in red, blue, and green yarns. The center features the text "Bicrafty Stitch-Nite Marly Bird" in colorful lettering on a white background. Flowers and knitting tools are also visible. -Marly Bird

    Q: What skill level is required for the make-along?
    A: This make-along is perfect for advanced beginners to intermediate crafters who are comfortable with the basics of knitting or crochet.

    Q: What yarn should I use?
    🧶 The Bellini Crochet Sweater is made with fingering weight yarn. Specifically WeCrochet Hawthorne Fingering. But we also would suggest these yarns: Comfy Fingering, Twill Fingering, Yarn Citizen Fingering, Malabrigo Ultimate Sock Yarn, or splurge and go with Madelintosh Tosh Merino Light.
    🧶 The Sandra PDA Knit Sweater is made with worsted weight yarn. Specifically Madelinetosh Vintage. But we also would suggest these yarns: Brava Worsted, Swish Worsted, Twill Worsted, Wool of the Andes Worsted, Berroco Ultra Wool.

    Q: Where can I get help if I’m stuck?
    A: You can ask questions during the weekly live Q&A sessions on the Marly Bird YouTube channel or seek support from the Marly Bird Facebook community.

    Q: Do I need to sign up or register?
    A: Yes! Please let us know you want to join the fun and we will send you the full material list for both sweaters. Then you simply choose your pattern, get your materials, and start crafting along with us.
    Also, We do highly recommend joining the facebook group and subscribing to the Marly Bird YouTube Channel.

    This or That Make-Along 2024

    Join the fun with hundreds of other knitters and crocheters for this free Marly Bird Make-Along

      We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

      Q: What if I can’t finish on time?
      A: If you are following with the free patterns ❣️ Note: the free Sandra PDA Knit Sweater will only be free for the duration of the make-along. However, if you purchase the ad-free pdf’s you have no worries! You can work at your own pace as you will own the full pattern.

      Q: Can I share my progress on social media?
      A: Absolutely! We encourage you to share your progress using the hashtags #mmmdi and #thisorthat. We’d love to see your work and feature it in our Stories and posts!


      We can’t wait to see what you create in the This or That Make-Along. Whether you choose the Bellini Crochet Sweater or the Sandra PDA Knit Sweater, you’re in for a creative adventure that’s as fun as it is rewarding. Happy crafting!

      Leave a Comment

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *